Once players develop their identity - understanding what makes them effective - we can push their development further.
The concept is simple but powerful: Position and a Half.
As a defender, you must not only do your job, but also do half the job for the defenders either side of you. This insight from the famous Liverpool boot room coaches captures something important about modern football.
But I’ve expanded this idea beyond defending into a complete development framework.
The Modern Demand
The game is always evolving. The demands on players to be multi-skilled increase every year.
Players regularly rotate positions to disrupt compact defences. This means they need a wide variety of attributes to succeed - not just the skills for one role, but the ability to operate effectively when the game shifts them elsewhere.
Three Full-Backs, Three Identities
Consider three elite right-backs with completely different profiles:
Player A: A right defender whose second position is central midfielder. Can switch roles via rotation or game-to-game selection. Equally skilled as a footballing full-back or a controlling midfielder who begins build-up play.
Player B: A right defender with qualities to attack like a winger. Elite techniques to outplay 1v1, create and score goals. Excellent athletic ability covering high distances at high intensity.
Player C: A right defender outstanding in 1v1 defensive situations. Bigger and stronger, perhaps not the same passing quality or attacking ability, but naturally suited to centre-back as a secondary position. Uses strength, heading ability, and game-reading to dominate opponents.
All three are right defenders at the highest level. All completely different. All have a clear “position and a half.”
The Key Questions
Every player should be able to answer:
-
What is your best position? The position where you believe you play at your best.
-
What is your position and a half? The secondary role you find yourself in through team selection or in-game rotation.
-
What does your second position demand from you?
-
What do you need to add to your game?
-
What are you obsessive about developing each day?
The Full Demands
Take an attacking full-back as an example. To operate at the highest level, they need to:
- Defend like a top full-back
- Have the physical capacity to constantly travel up and down the pitch
- Once in the final third, have quality to outplay 1v1 or combine with teammates
- Be able to cross or shoot effectively
They cannot be a defender when they’re in attacking positions. In those moments, they must move and play like an attacker.
That’s an exhausting list of demands. But this is what elite football requires.
At every level, people constantly assess and judge players. Your daily training “diet” must prepare and develop you for these specific, personal demands.
Confidence Through Competence
There’s a crucial insight here about player confidence:
“A player’s confidence and self-belief does not come from coaches or managers. It comes from the knowledge that during a game, you are comfortable in any situation or position you find yourself in.”
This is why the position-and-a-half concept matters for development. Players who can only operate in one specific role carry fear into games - fear of being exposed when situations shift.
Moving Minds
Part of your job as a coach is constantly pushing players to think about “what ifs.”
For young players, fear on a football pitch equals the moment you’re put under pressure to execute a weakness.
Questions that provoke self-assessment:
-
In the last five minutes, the ball is crossed to the far post and you have a chance to head and score - do you score? (Are your heading techniques elite?)
-
In the first minute of your debut, a quality winger runs at you 1v1 - will you stop them? (Are your 1v1 defending techniques elite?)
-
In the last minute, a ball arrives on your weak foot 20 metres from goal - do you score or miss? (How comfortable are you striking with both feet?)
This questioning keeps players in a growth mindset.
On your debut, you don’t want to be HOPING things will be okay. You need to have PREPARED in the days, weeks, months, and years before that moment.
Position-Specific Development Questions
For strikers: What types of goals do you score? Understand this and practice these techniques daily. What types of chances do you miss?
For wide players: What type of opponent do you succeed against? What type causes problems? How is your crossing? What type is your strength? What types need improvement? Do you cross effectively with both feet? What type of goals do you score?
For every position: The questions multiply when you genuinely assess what each role demands.
The Communication Priority
Building relationships and communicating 1-to-1 is enormously important for youth coaches.
Here’s something that needs more emphasis in coach education: 1-to-1 conversations on identity and mindset are often more influential than any coaching inside the pitch.
The skill of understanding each player, knowing what they need to develop, and communicating this effectively - this is where real development happens.
The Practical Application
Always praise effort and application from players showing willingness to improve.
Help “remove the fluff” and adjust training with careful advice to stimulate continued development.
Improving anything in life is easier when following a process. Break things down. Take small steps each day.
The position-and-a-half framework gives players a clear development target. They know their primary role. They know their secondary contribution. They understand what each demands.
This clarity transforms random training into purposeful development.
Ready to develop versatile, confident players? The 328 Training Sessions include position-specific development progressions for every role.
Join 1,600+ coaches in the Football Coaching Academy where we discuss player identity and positional development.
Quick question about player development? FootballGPT provides instant coaching guidance 24/7 - free to start.