Dave had twelve coaching apps on his phone.
Eight YouTube channel subscriptions. A Pinterest board with five hundred saved drills. Three physical notebooks full of session ideas from coaching conferences.
His players could not pass ten yards consistently.
I met Dave at a coaching course. He was enthusiastic, dedicated, and completely overwhelmed. Every Sunday night, he had scroll through his collection looking for Tuesday’s session. Every Sunday night, he felt lost.
“I have more resources than I could ever use,” he said. “But I do not know what I am actually trying to develop.”
Dave had confused activity with progress. And he is not alone.
The Pinterest Trap I Recognised
Dave described his typical week. Monday he found a “Barcelona possession drill” on YouTube. Players struggled with the technical demands but completed the activity. Wednesday a different video caught his eye, something about Liverpool’s high-intensity pressing. Players ran around a lot. Some pressing happened.
Saturday arrived. Match day. His players reverted to their baseline abilities because nothing they had practiced actually connected or built on previous learning.
The problem was not the individual drills. Many YouTube coaching videos show excellent exercises. The problem was lack of context, progression, and connection.
I had made the same mistake years earlier. I had see Pep’s training sessions online and run them Tuesday with my U12s. The exercise that worked brilliantly for Barcelona’s technical masters did not work for players who could not receive a pass without looking at the ball.
Without understanding why, when, and how to use specific exercises, you are not coaching. You are just facilitating random activity.
What Actually Develops Players
Dave asked me what he should do differently. I explained what fifteen years of systematic coaching had taught me.
Players improve through clear learning objectives where they understand what they are trying to achieve. Through appropriate challenge levels that are hard enough to grow from but achievable enough to build confidence. Through systematic progression where each session builds on previous learning. Through consistent repetition that masters skills before adding complexity. Through game connection that shows how training transfers to matches.
Notice what is not on that list. Having five hundred different drills.
Dave’s collection was enormous, but it was just a pile of disconnected exercises. A good session library needs organisation, not just volume.
The Progressive Approach That Changed Everything
I showed Dave how systematic training actually works. Instead of random drill selection, you plan in connected blocks.
Weeks one and two establish foundation. Ball mastery with both feet. Players need technical confidence before adding pressure. Sessions focus on individual ball work, stationary receives, basic passing. Success rate should be high because you are building the base.
Weeks three and four introduce pressure. You are applying foundation skills under light challenge. This bridges isolated skill and game application. Sessions feature partner pressure, simple 1v1s, receiving on the move. Success rate drops slightly because challenge increases.
Weeks five and six develop decision-making. Players choose when and how to apply skills. Real football requires reading situations, not just executing techniques. Sessions include multiple option drills, small-sided games with conditions. Success rate varies because decisions matter now.
Weeks seven and eight focus on game application. Transferring skills to match situations. This is the ultimate test of whether training is working. Sessions feature position-specific scenarios, modified games, full application under match-realistic pressure.
Each phase builds on the previous one. Players do not just learn skills. They understand when and why to use them.
The Age-Appropriate Problem
Dave also struggled with age-appropriateness. That brilliant drill he found for Premier League players was completely wrong for his development level.
I watched another grassroots coach attempt a complex passing pattern he had seen Manchester City practicing. His U11s spent twenty minutes confused, frustrated, and learning nothing. They lacked the foundation skills to execute the exercise.
For younger players around U11 age, you need to ask foundation questions. Can they receive a pass without looking at the ball? Can they pass ten yards accurately with both feet? Do they understand basic positioning and movement? Master these first. Everything else builds on top.
For developing players around U14 age, the questions change. Can they receive under pressure and make quick decisions? Do they understand when to pass, dribble, or shoot? Can they execute skills consistently under match pressure?
For older players around U17 age, the questions mature further. Can they adapt skills to different tactical systems? Do they understand their role within team structures? Can they perform under physical and mental pressure?
The same drill might be perfect for one age group and completely wrong for another. Context matters more than content.
The Hidden Cost Dave Had not Counted
When you run sessions without systematic progression, several things happen that Dave had not noticed.
Players do not improve. They get better at doing drills, not playing football. Technical ability stagnates because there is no logical skill building.
Confidence drops. Constantly learning new exercises means never mastering anything. Players feel like they are always starting over.
Game transfer fails. Random training does not connect to match situations. Players cannot apply what they practice.
Time gets wasted. You spend sessions teaching new exercises instead of developing football skills.
Players lose interest. Without clear progress markers, football feels pointless and frustrating.
Dave realised his U13s had spent eighteen months doing random activities. They were not measurably better at anything specific because nothing had been systematically developed.
Building Structure From Chaos
Dave asked how to transition from his current approach. I gave him a simple four-week process.
This week, choose one skill area and commit to developing it systematically for the next month. Pick something specific like passing, receiving, 1v1s, or shooting.
Next week, map your four-week progression from basic to game application. Week one foundation, week two adding pressure, week three adding decisions, week four match application.
Week three, resist the urge to try new drills. Stick to your systematic plan even when YouTube tempts you with something shiny.
Week four, evaluate progress. Are players actually better at this skill in matches? If yes, the approach is working. If no, adjust and try again.
Month two, apply the same systematic approach to your next skill area.
Dave followed this process. Six weeks later, he messaged me. “My players can actually receive and pass now. Not perfectly, but consistently. And I know exactly why.”
The Real Problem With Drill Collection
Dave’s five hundred saved drills were not the problem. The problem was using them without understanding the bigger picture of player development.
Every drill, exercise, and activity should serve a clear purpose within a systematic progression. Random activity might look like coaching, but it does not develop players.
I still watch YouTube coaching videos. I still save exercises that look interesting. But now they go into a structured system, not a random pile.
The coach with twenty core exercises who understands progression will always outperform the coach with five hundred exercises who does not.
Your players deserve better than drill collection. They deserve systematic development that creates lasting improvement.
Dave deleted three of his coaching apps. He kept his Pinterest board but reorganised it by development phase instead of by random topic. His Sunday nights went from stressful scrolling to confident adaptation.
The resources did not change. The approach did.
Ready for a systematic approach that replaces drill collection with purposeful development?
The Football Coaching Academy provides the complete framework for progressive player development. Join 1,600+ coaches who stopped collecting and started developing. $1/month to start.