My first coaching session lasted seventy-three minutes. For approximately forty of those minutes, players were standing still while I explained things.
Passing technique. Body positioning. When to release the ball. The differences between different passing surfaces. Tactical considerations for playing out from the back.
The eight-year-olds stared at me with glazed eyes. Some fidgeted. One picked grass. Another wandered toward the water bottles despite my mid-explanation.
I thought I was coaching. I was lecturing.
The Realisation
That session taught me the first mistake new coaches make: talking too much. But it took months before I understood why.
I had knowledge I wanted to share. I assumed sharing it meant explaining it. But explanation is not learning. Experience is learning. My job was not to tell players what to do. My job was to create situations where they discovered what to do.
The following week, I spoke for maybe ten minutes total. The rest of the session, players played. They made mistakes. They figured things out. They touched the ball hundreds of times instead of dozens.
More happened in that session than in any session I had run before.
Everything At Once
My second mistake revealed itself through player confusion.
One week we worked on passing. The next week, dribbling. The week after that, defending. Then shooting. Then movement. Each session introduced something new because I thought variety meant progress.
Players never mastered anything. They experienced passing once, then moved on before the technique became automatic. They tried dribbling once, then forgot it while we worked on something else.
A mentor asked me what our team’s development priorities were for the season. I listed twelve things. He laughed.
“Pick three,” he said. “Spend four weeks on each one. Your players will actually improve at those three things instead of slightly experiencing twelve things.”
That advice transformed my planning. Four-week blocks focused on one primary skill. Week one without pressure. Week two with passive defenders. Week three with active opposition. Week four in game situations.
Players finished those blocks actually better at things. Not just exposed to things.
The Winning Trap
The first time we won comfortably, I felt like a real coach. The scoreline validated my methods. The parents congratulated me. The players were happy.
So I did more of what had worked. Played my best players more. Used formations that protected leads. Focused training on match preparation rather than individual development.
We kept winning. But by mid-season, something had shifted. Our weaker players had not improved. They had actually regressed from lack of meaningful game time. Our stronger players had plateaued because training had become about executing, not developing.
When we faced better opposition in knockout competition, we lost badly. The team that had won through superior players had nothing when facing equally talented opponents.
I had prioritised results over development. The results eventually stopped, and I had nothing to show for the season except a league position that meant nothing for player growth.
The Same Session For Everyone
Jake was eight. Sophie was eight. They were in the same age group. I coached them identically.
But Jake was confident to the point of recklessness. He had try anything without fear of failure. Sophie was technically excellent but hesitant. She had make the safe choice every time, even when a better option was available.
The same coaching approach affected them completely differently. When I challenged Jake to take risks, he was already doing it. The instruction was redundant. When I challenged Sophie to take risks, she heard criticism of her caution rather than encouragement toward growth.
Jake needed boundaries and decision-making guidance. Sophie needed confidence-building and permission to fail. Same age group. Different coaching needs.
The realisation expanded. Every player needed something different. Some learned by watching. Others needed to feel the movement. Some responded to direct instruction. Others needed questions that led them to answers.
One-size-fits-all coaching does not fit anyone particularly well.
The Unprepared Days
Some sessions I arrived with detailed plans. Those sessions ran smoothly. Other sessions I arrived with vague ideas. Those sessions fell apart.
The vague-idea sessions always went the same way. Activity that did not work. Scrambling for alternatives. Long explanations while I figured out what to do next. Players losing focus while I improvised.
Preparation is not about perfection. It is about having answers ready before questions arise. Knowing what equipment you need. Knowing what progressions are possible if something’s too easy or too hard. Knowing what you will do if it rains or if three players do not show up.
The fifteen minutes I spend planning save hours of frustration. The sessions where I arrive prepared feel completely different from the sessions where I wing it.
The Negative Feedback Loop
Early in my coaching, I focused on mistakes. A bad pass drew immediate correction. A missed chance prompted instruction about technique. Every error became a teaching opportunity.
Players became hesitant. They stopped trying creative solutions because creativity meant risk of failure, and failure meant correction. They played safe passes to avoid hearing what they had done wrong.
I was coaching fear into them.
The shift came when I started focusing on what went right rather than what went wrong. Highlighting good decisions. Celebrating attempts even when they failed. Framing corrections as additions rather than critiques.
“Great idea to play that pass. Next time, try using the outside of your foot for more disguise.”
The same information, delivered as building on success rather than correcting failure. Players started trying things again. Risk-taking returned. Development accelerated.
The Age Group Confusion
My methods for eight-year-olds came from watching professional football. Complex tactical explanations. Positional discipline. Systems of play.
None of it worked because eight-year-olds are not small professionals. Their attention spans are shorter. Their cognitive development cannot process abstract tactical concepts. Their priority is enjoyment, not achievement.
When I adapted for age, everything improved. Sessions for young players became shorter activities with more variety. Instructions became simpler. The focus shifted from tactical understanding to ball familiarity and confidence.
Older players could handle longer activities. They could process tactical concepts. They wanted competitive challenge and detailed feedback.
The session that is perfect for twelve-year-olds bores eight-year-olds and under-challenges sixteen-year-olds. Age-appropriate coaching is not just about difficulty level. It is about understanding how different ages learn.
The Mental Blind Spot
For two years, every session focused on technical or tactical development. Passing. Movement. Formations. Decision-making.
I ignored the mental side entirely. Confidence. Pressure management. Resilience. Focus. I assumed these either existed naturally or could not be coached.
Then I noticed patterns. Players who performed brilliantly in training disappeared in matches. Players who handled routine situations fell apart in crucial moments. Players who bounced back from mistakes versus players who spiraled after them.
Mental skills can be coached. Creating pressure situations in training prepares players for match pressure. Building in failure and recovery teaches resilience. Celebrating effort rather than just outcome builds confidence.
The mental work does not replace technical development. It enables it. The player with excellent technique who cannot handle pressure never shows that technique when it matters.
The Stagnation Problem
By year three, I had sessions that worked. Activities players enjoyed. Structures that produced development. Methods I trusted.
So I stopped learning. Used the same sessions repeatedly. Stopped watching other coaches. Stopped reading. Stopped questioning whether my methods were actually optimal.
My coaching plateaued because I had stopped growing. Players still developed, but my contribution had become repetitive rather than evolving.
The coaches who keep improving are the ones who keep learning. Watching sessions. Attending courses. Asking questions. Trying new approaches. Reflecting honestly on what is working and what is not.
Coaching development does not end when you feel competent. That is when it needs to accelerate.
The Parent Management Failure
Parents were not part of my coaching plan. I coached players. Parents watched. Simple.
Until parents started coaching from the sideline. Started questioning decisions. Started creating pressure that undermined the environment I was trying to build.
The missing piece was communication. Parents needed to understand the philosophy. They needed to know why I made certain decisions. They needed boundaries around what support looked like.
A pre-season meeting changed everything. Explaining our approach. Setting expectations for sideline behavior. Creating channels for questions that did not involve shouting during matches.
Managing parents is not separate from coaching players. It is part of creating the environment where coaching can actually work.
What I Wish I had Known
Every mistake I made cost players development time. Sessions wasted on too much talking. Months wasted on scattered planning. Seasons wasted on prioritising results.
New coaches do not need to make these mistakes themselves. The patterns are predictable. The solutions are known. Learning from others’ errors is faster than discovering them personally.
Talk less. Focus on fewer things but actually develop them. Prioritise development over winning. Adapt to individual players. Prepare thoroughly. Stay positive. Understand age differences. Coach the mental game. Keep learning. Manage parents proactively.
None of this is complicated. All of it matters.
Your players deserve a coach who has learned these lessons. Whether you learn them through your own painful mistakes or through the experiences of those who have made them before you is your choice.
Ready to skip the learning curve?
The Football Coaching Academy brings together 1,600+ coaches sharing what actually works. Learn from experienced coaches who have made these mistakes so you do not have to. $1/month to start.