The message arrived at 11:47pm on a Sunday night.
“Kevin, my team bunches up no matter what I do. I have tried everything. Different formations. Shouting instructions. Even putting cones where players should stand. Nothing works. What am I missing?”
I would received hundreds of similar messages over the years. Coaches describing problems, listing failed solutions, looking for the answer that would fix everything.
This particular message got me thinking about something fundamental. Why do some solutions work while others fail completely?
The answer changed everything about how I approach coaching problems.
The Six Weeks That Taught Me Nothing
My own team could not keep possession under pressure. The problem was obvious. Every time opponents pressed, we gave the ball away.
I knew the solution. More passing drills. Better technique. Players needed to become more comfortable on the ball.
So I ran passing exercises for six weeks. Short passing. Long passing. Passing triangles. Passing sequences. Every session included extended passing work.
Six weeks later, we still could not keep possession under pressure.
The drills had improved something. Players could execute passing patterns without opposition. Their technique in isolated situations had developed. But the moment pressure arrived, everything fell apart.
I had been solving the wrong problem.
The Diagnosis That Changed Everything
A coach I respected watched one of our matches. Afterwards, I asked what he had noticed.
“Your players can pass,” he said. “That is not the issue.”
“Then why cannot we keep the ball under pressure?”
“Watch them receive. Watch their first touch when a defender is close. Watch what happens before the pass.”
I went back through footage and saw what I would missed. The passing was not the problem. The receiving was. Players could not control the ball when opponents were near. Their first touch was adequate in space but inadequate under pressure.
I had spent six weeks treating a symptom. The actual disease was completely different.
The Questions I Should Have Asked
The bunching problem that coach messaged me about followed the same pattern. He assumed the problem was positioning. So he tried solutions that addressed positioning. Cones to show where players should stand. Instructions about spreading out. Formation adjustments.
None of it worked because positioning was not the real problem.
Players bunch for reasons. They might not understand why width matters. They might lack confidence to receive the ball in wide areas. They might have learned that bunching gets rewarded because they are more likely to touch the ball. The training environment itself might be encouraging the behaviour.
Until you understand the actual cause, solutions address symptoms. And symptom treatment rarely fixes anything permanently.
The questions I should have asked about my own possession problem were different from what I assumed. Not “How can we pass better?” but “what is actually happening when we lose the ball?” Not “What drill will fix this?” but “What skill is actually failing in match situations?”
What Real Diagnosis Looks Like
That coach who watched my match taught me a diagnostic approach I still use today.
When a problem appears, I resist the urge to design solutions immediately. Instead, I ask specific questions.
When does this problem happen most? With possession, it happened during build-up play, not in the final third. That narrowed the issue.
Which players are involved? Everyone struggled, but centre backs and central midfielders most. That suggested the problem was most acute in areas where pressure was highest.
What happens immediately before the problem? I watched footage and noticed players were fine until the opponent closed within two yards. Then everything collapsed. The proximity of pressure was the trigger.
What happens when players try to do it correctly? When they attempted to receive with a defender close, their first touch was too heavy. They knew what to do but could not execute it.
These questions pointed toward receiving under pressure as the actual issue. Not passing. Not positioning. Not tactics. A specific technical deficiency under specific conditions.
The Solution That Worked
Once I understood the real problem, the solution became obvious.
I stopped running passing drills. Instead, I created receiving exercises where defenders were always close. Not far enough away to be comfortable. Close enough to create the pressure that matched situations produced.
Players received the ball with a defender arriving. They practised first touches with someone on their shoulder. They developed comfort in situations that had previously caused panic.
Within three weeks, the possession problem improved noticeably. Not because players could suddenly pass better. Because they could receive under pressure well enough to have passing options.
The six weeks of passing work had been wasted. The three weeks of correctly diagnosed work produced results.
The Pattern I See Repeatedly
The coach with the bunching problem discovered his real issue was different from positioning. His players bunched because they felt safer together. Spreading out meant receiving the ball in areas where they would previously struggled. The bunching was a rational response to technical insecurity.
His solution needed to address the underlying insecurity, not the surface behaviour. When he started building confidence in wide receiving situations, players naturally spread out. They were not being forced to positions they feared. They were becoming comfortable in positions that now felt manageable.
I see this pattern constantly. Finishing problems that are actually first touch problems. Decision-making problems that are actually information problems. Tactical problems that are actually skill confidence problems.
The surface symptom and the underlying cause are rarely the same thing. Coaches who solve the symptom keep facing it repeatedly. Coaches who solve the cause watch it disappear.
The Questions That Reveal Root Causes
Whenever I face a coaching problem now, I work through specific questions before designing any solution.
What can players see in the moment the problem occurs? Sometimes problems happen because players do not have enough information. They cannot see options that exist because their positioning or body shape limits their view.
What options do players actually have? Sometimes problems happen because better options do not exist. The “wrong” choice might be the only choice available given the circumstances.
What happens when players try different approaches? Sometimes problems happen because consequences have taught players to avoid certain actions. A player who lost possession attempting a switch might stop trying switches entirely.
Do players have the technical ability to execute the right choice? Sometimes problems happen because the solution requires skills players have not developed. Knowing the right answer does not help if you cannot do the right answer.
These questions separate diagnosis from assumption. They point toward root causes rather than surface symptoms.
The Transformation In My Coaching
This diagnostic approach transformed how I design sessions.
Every training activity now connects to a diagnosed problem. Not a general topic I think we should cover. A specific issue I have observed, investigated, and understood.
When I plan possession work, it is because I have identified something specific about how we are losing the ball. The activity recreates that specific situation and allows players to develop solutions.
When I plan finishing work, it is because I have diagnosed what is actually going wrong in front of goal. The activity addresses that specific deficiency, not generic shooting practice.
This precision means less wasted time. Sessions target real problems rather than assumed problems. Improvement becomes visible because we are actually fixing things that need fixing.
What This Means For Your Coaching
Think about a problem your team faces repeatedly. Something that keeps appearing despite your efforts to address it.
Ask yourself whether you have actually diagnosed the root cause or just observed the surface symptom. Have you watched footage to understand what is really happening? Have you asked players what they experience in those moments? Have you tested whether the problem is technical, tactical, physical, or psychological?
If you have been addressing symptoms, the problem will keep returning. Your solutions might temporarily suppress it, but the underlying cause remains.
If you diagnose the actual cause, solutions become obvious. The right approach reveals itself because you understand what you are actually trying to fix.
The six weeks I wasted on passing drills taught me this lesson permanently. I was working hard at the wrong problem. Hard work at the wrong problem produces nothing.
Work smarter by diagnosing accurately. Then the work you do actually matters.
Ready to learn systematic problem diagnosis?
The Football Coaching Academy is where 1,800+ coaches develop diagnostic skills that reveal root causes instead of chasing symptoms. Analysis tools, peer discussion, and frameworks that transform how you solve coaching problems. Current membership terms are shown on Skool.